ID 154205 - NukeStudio wrong definition of retimed clips in exported XML, duration in/out do not match FCP XML

Follow

Problem summary
Projects with certain types of clips have problems with the XML files generated from NukeStudio


"Retimed clips are not correctly defined in the XML from NukeStudio...
I created a more complete test case to show the errors of the xml
interpretation in NukeStudio.

Steps to reproduce

I created a sequence in NukeStudio 9.0v2 and recreated the same sequence
in Final Cut Pro. The sequence contains four instances of the same
'testing.mov' clip at different speeds.

I exported xml's from both applications and compared them :
*
*
*
*
*
*
First, a clip at 100% speed, with trimmed in and out points :

/NS : lines 34-42:
/

testing
100

FALSE
25

50.0
60.0

FCP : lines 76-82


testing
100

FALSE
25

50
60/

No problems here


========================================


Second clip in the sequence, a reversed clip (ie -100% speed)

/NS : lines 75-83 :
/

testing
100

FALSE
25

59.0
79.0

FCP : lines 165-173 :


testing
100

FALSE
25

40
60/

As you can see the in and out numbers are not identical between fcp and
nukestudio. They should be.


============================================

Third clip : a clip at 396% speed (I tried 400% first but FCP will
change my input of 400% to 396%, so I did a retime of 396% in both NS
and FCP)

/NS: lines 130-138
/

testing
100

FALSE
25

40.0
50.0

FCP : lines 286-294


testing
26

FALSE
25

10
20/


Here the duration in FCP is the duration with the retime included (100 /
3.96 = 25.25, here rounded to 26) and the in point in FCP is also
expressed with the retime already included, so it's 10 instead of 40
like in Nukestudio.


==============================================

Fourth and last clip : a clip at -200%
/
NS : lines 185-193


testing
100

FALSE
25

69.0
84.0

FCP : lines 407-415


testing
50

FALSE
25

15
30/
/
//
Here also the duration, in and out values are not identical.



    We're sorry to hear that

    Please tell us why