State:New|TargetRelease:No Target|icon_bug|icon_nuke|database:public|Resolution:Fixed|BugID:156435|
Problem summary:
EDL files with KEY events are not imported correctly in Nuke Studio/Hiero
Customer reported version:
Hiero N/A
Customer reported platform:
macOS 11 Big Sur
Steps to reproduce:
1) Download the attached example.edl file and launch Nuke Studio.
2) Navigate to File > Import EDL/XML/AAF... and select the example.edl file.
3) Observe how the Clips have been imported as overlapping events on the first Track:

Expected behavior:
Nuke Studio/Hiero should import EDL files without issue, regardless of the event types contained within.
Actual behavior:
When importing an EDL that has KEY events, these Clips will not be positioned correctly on the Timeline and may overlap other non-KEY items.
Workaround:
Although there is no workaround at this time for the EDL import behavior, it is possible to move all Clips with KEY metadata to a different Track with Python, like the following example code:
timeline = hiero.ui.getTimelineEditor(hiero.ui.activeSequence()) sel = timeline.selection() # get the selected TrackItems track2 = hiero.core.VideoTrack("Test V2") # create a new Track in this Sequence timeline.sequence().addTrack(track2) for clip in sel: data = clip.metadata()["foundry.edl.comments"] for line in data.split("\n"): if "KEY" in line: # remove the Clip from its current Track, and move it to track2 clip.parentTrack().removeItem(clip) track2.addItem(clip) break
Reproduced by Support in:
Nuke Studio 15.0v4 - Windows 10, macOS 13 Ventura
Nuke Studio 14.1v1 - Windows 10
Nuke Studio 14.0v1 - Windows 10
Nuke Studio 13.0v1 - Windows 10
Nuke Studio 12.0v1 - Windows 10
Earliest version tested:
Nuke Studio 12.0v1 - This issue appears to be in all tested versions of the product
We're sorry to hear that
Please tell us why